Why Bother With Predestination?


Last Sunday, we were taken to one of the pinnacles of theological thought as we considered the doctrine of predestination. Throughout history theologians have apprehended this biblical concept in divergent ways, fostering two main streams of thought known today as Calvinism and Arminianism. To gain a better understanding of these ideas, we need to look back to a theological dispute that emerged in the 5th Century and crystalized in the 1600s.


The Early Church: A Synergist View of Predestination

The doctrine of predestination took shape in the early years of church history. It was understood as God’s electing of some sinners for salvation before the foundation of the earth (Ephesians 1:4).

Yet, amongst a culture that featured notions of fatalism and absolute determinism, it was important for the early church fathers to emphasise the role of human free will in choosing salvation. Collating passages that spoke of God’s sovereignty in effecting salvation and man’s responsibility to choose God, they were led to conclude that salvation was the result of a cooperative effort between God and man. This is otherwise known as a synergist view: In predestination, God both foreknew those who would choose Him, and willed them to be saved. Clement of Alexandria sums it up, saying, ‘God conspires with willing people.’


Pelagius and Augustine

In the 5th Century, a monk by the name of Pelagius (390-418) departed from synergism by affirming that man is born sinless and has the ability to choose and attain salvation without God’s help. Pelagius thus reduced the idea of predestination to foreknowledge, and evacuated God’s active will from the act of salvation.

Theologian Augustine of Hippo (354-430) soon challenged Pelagius’ view. He understood Adam’s sin as having corrupted human nature: Man was born a sinner, incapable of choosing God, therefore needing God’s saving grace to bring him out of total depravity. Augustine believed that God did not will all people to be saved; rather, in His sovereign will, He chose the elect and them only for salvation. Consequently, salvation was from beginning (predestination) to end (glorification) a work of God alone. This view is known as monergism.

In 529 the church convened a Synod at Orange to resolve the conflicting views of Pelagianism and Augustinianism. On most items the Synod sided with the Augustinian view but remained undecided on the doctrine of predestination.


The Rudiments of Calvinism

The discussion thus carried on into the 16th Century, as the Protestant Reformation spread throughout Europe. Martin Luther clearly stated his view; ‘Our will is unimportant, God’s will and choosing are decisive.’ But, perhaps more than any other Reformer, French theologian John Calvin (1509-1564) was most captivated by the doctrine of predestination. He taught that predestination is ‘God’s eternal decree, by which he compacted with himself what he willed to become of each person […] Eternal life is foreordained for some, eternal damnation for others.’ This election is not based on human worth or effort, but on God’s pleasing will. In the exposition of this doctrine, he highlighted the grace of God towards undeserving sinners, and encouraged believers to persevere in humility and hope.


The Five Points of Arminianism

It was some fifty years later that Dutch theologian Jacob Arminius (1560-1609) refuted Calvin’s doctrine of predestination. He preached that salvation is a product of the human will rather than divine appointing, and understood the doctrine of predestination to refer to God’s choosing of those whom He knows will choose him.

Arminius’ followers compiled his teachings in five articles of faith, known as The Five Points of Arminianism. These are:

  1. Free Will: each sinner possesses a free will, and his eternal destiny depends on how he uses it to accept or reject God’s offer of salvation;
  2. Conditional Election: God elects or reproves on the basis of man’s foreseen choice;
  3. General Atonement: Christ died for all men, although only believers are saved;
  4. Resistible Grace: God’s grace in calling us to himself for salvation may be resisted;
  5. Perseverance of Some Saints: those who believe and are truly saved can lose their salvation by failing to keep up their faith.


The Five Points of Calvinism

When these articles were published at the turn of the 17th Century, the Dutch Reformed Church called a national Synod to meet in Dort in order to examine the views of Arminius in light of Scripture. 84 members gathered over a seven-month period of time, and rejected the five doctrines advanced by the Arminians as heretical. In response, the Synod compiled John Calvin’s teachings into The Five Points of Calvinism. These are:

  1. Total Depravity: because of the fall, man is sinful and depraved in every facet, unable of himself to believe the gospel, it is God’s work from beginning to end;
  2. Unconditional Election: God chooses individuals for salvation before the foundation of the world, not based on their works, or will or reason but out of His sovereign and secret will;
  3. Limited Atonement: Christ’s death purchased common grace for all, but His redeeming work was intended to save and secure salvation only for the elect;
  4. Irresistible Grace: those God has called cannot resist His call;
  5. Perseverance of All Saints: all of the elect will be effectively saved and kept until the end.


Why all the fuss?

For many believers today, discussing the doctrine of predestination seems either pompous or irrelevant. Yet there are many reasons why it is wise for us to follow our Christian brothers and sisters before us who have wrestled with this issue. First, God is glorified when we use the minds he has given us to think deeply about the truth He has revealed to us. Indeed, while the ‘secret things belong to the Lord our God’, ‘the things that are revealed belong to us and to our children forever’ (Deuteronomy 29:29). God has revealed much in His word about the plan, purpose and process of salvation. Given that all Scripture is profitable (2 Timothy 3:16), we do well to wrestle through this revelation. Second, we will know our Saviour more intimately if we have a clearer idea of the way He saved us. This should lead us to worship Him. Finally, if we are truly awed by God’s work in salvation, we should be humbled by His sovereignty, and encouraged to seek Him further.

For an unpacking of both views, and clarity on City on a Hill’s position, please listen to Guy Mason’s sermon 'If God Predestined People To Salvation, Why Bother With Evangelism?'.


Further reading

Chosen by God – by R.C. Sproul
For Calvinism – by Michael Horton
Against Calvinism – by Roger Olson

Author: Sarah Frewen-Lord
Published: 04 Oct 2013

Latest Posts:

  • Join the Team – Community Pastor (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Generations Pastor (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Women’s Ministry Director (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Training Director (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – City Kids Coordinator (West)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – City on a Hill Melbourne

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Services Director (West)

    Join the Team –…

  • Key Themes: Suffering

    Key Themes: Suffering

  • Key Themes: Poverty & Wealth

    Key Themes: Poverty…

  • Key Themes: Now & Tomorrow

    Key Themes: Now &…

  • Key Themes: Wisdom

    Key Themes: Wisdom

  • Key Themes: Faith & Works

    Key Themes: Faith…

  • Opportunity to Serve – Communications Coordinator Melbourne

    Opportunity to Serve…

  • Fasting: A Brief Introduction

    Fasting: A Brief…

  • Unlocking a New Room

    Unlocking a New Room

  • Join the Team – Many Rooms Kitchen Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • Opportunity to Serve – City Kids Team Leader

    Opportunity to Serve…

  • On Mission with Milene Tan

    On Mission with Milene…

  • On Mission with Kenneth Webb

    On Mission with Kenneth…

  • On Mission with Debbie Bognar

    On Mission with Debbie…

  • The Structure of Proverbs

    The Structure of…

  • City on a Hill Church Planting Fund

    City on a Hill Church…

  • His Story Our Story – Recap

    His Story Our Story…

  • 3 Tips for Reading Proverbs

    3 Tips for Reading…

  • Join the Team – Research Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • Why should we trust the Bible if it gets the origin of life so wrong? – Part III

    Why should we trust…

  • Why should we trust the Bible if it gets the origin of life so wrong? – Part II

    Why should we trust…

  • Why should we trust the Bible if it gets the origin of life so wrong? – Part I

    Why should we trust…

  • Tacos of Grace

    Tacos of Grace

  • City News September

    City News September

  • City News August

    City News August

  • Join the Team – Operations Director

    Join the Team –…

  • Welcome Dave Miers

    Welcome Dave Miers

  • City News July

    City News July

  • On Mission with Paul Distefano

    On Mission with Paul…

  • On Mission with Steve Murray

    On Mission with Steve…

  • On Mission with Rick Jordan

    On Mission with Rick…

  • Welcome Leighton Cantrill

    Welcome Leighton…

  • The Lost Art of Sorrow

    The Lost Art of Sorrow

  • Interview With Sam Wright, Pastor of Redemption Church

    Interview With Sam…

  • The Reality of Suffering and Evil

    The Reality of Suffering…

  • Join the Team – Accounts Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • The Attentive Life - Book Review

    The Attentive Life…

  • A Date with the King

    A Date with the King

  • Trusting the Grand Weaver

    Trusting the Grand…

  • City News February

    City News February

  • Songs of Summer II

    Songs of Summer II

  • City News January

    City News January

  • Generous – Quarterly Update

    Generous – Quarterly…

  • City News December

    City News December

  • Join the Team – Community Director

    Join the Team –…

  • Engage 2014

    Engage 2014

  • Planting with PlantED

    Planting with PlantED

  • Join the Team – Video Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • Introduction to Promises

    Introduction to Promises

  • Join the Team – XD-Ops

    Join the Team –…

  • City News November

    City News November

  • His Story Our Story – Photo Journal

    His Story Our Story…

  • Kirsty’s Story

    Kirsty’s Story

  • Pete’s Story

    Pete’s Story

  • Amy’s Story

    Amy’s Story

  • Surviving Same Sex Attraction as a Christian

    Surviving Same Sex…

  • Generous Campaign

    Generous Campaign

  • Why Bother With Predestination?

    Why Bother With Predestination?

  • City News October

    City News October

  • This Is (True) Greatness

    This Is (True) Greatness

  • The Call to Mission

    The Call to Mission

  • What About the Warnings?

    What About the Warnings?

  • The Peril of Porn

    The Peril of Porn

  • Dating For The Glory Of God

    Dating For The Glory…

  • City News September 2013

    City News September…

  • Adoption: The Gospel Made Visible

    Adoption: The Gospel…

  • You Knit Me Together

    You Knit Me Together

  • Working For God

    Working For God

  • Australia – The Results Are In

    Australia – The…

  • Thorn in the Flesh

    Thorn in the Flesh

  • Tough Questions

    Tough Questions

  • Good Grief

    Good Grief

  • An Honourable Office

    An Honourable Office

  • City News July 2013

    City News July 2013

  • Faith and Work

    Faith and Work

  • We Are Family

    We Are Family

  • WWJD: Responding To Begging

    WWJD: Responding…

  • Work. Rest. Play - Part II

    Work. Rest. Play…

  • City News - May

    City News - May

  • Salvation Happens To Us, Not By Us

    Salvation Happens…

  • Doves & Snakes

    Doves & Snakes

  • Planting & Pregnancy

    Planting & Pregnancy

  • Lest We Forget

    Lest We Forget

  • Introduction to 1 Peter

    Introduction to 1…

  • Easter 2013 – Photo Journal

    Easter 2013 – Photo…

  • More Than Gold

    More Than Gold

  • Join The Team – Music Director

    Join The Team –…

  • Jessica’s Story

    Jessica’s Story

  • Changes


  • Andy’s Story

    Andy’s Story

  • Work. Rest. Play - Part I

    Work. Rest. Play…

  • Join The Team – Biblical Living Pastor

    Join The Team –…

  • Eat, Drink & Be Merry Melbourne!

    Eat, Drink &…

  • City News – March

    City News – March