What About the Warnings?


The past Sunday, one of our PlantED interns, Sam Wright, answered the ‘tough question’ ‘Can a Christian lose their salvation?’. Following that, Sam addressed an objection to his answer of that question, that a Christian indeed cannot be lost, because God never loses one of His own. The objection arises however: what about the passages in Scripture that warn us against falling away?

The question of whether a Christian can lose their salvation is both simple and complicated. It is simple in that Jesus explicitly promises that none can be snatched out of his hand (John 10:26–30). It is immediately complicated by the presence of warning passages which seem to put Christian salvation at stake.

There are passages which demand perseverance to the end:

“Now I would remind you brothers, of the Gospel I preached to you, which you received, in which you stand, and by which you are being saved, if you hold fast to the word I preached to you—unless you believed in vain.”  (1 Corinthians 15:1–2)

Salvation is granted ’if’ we hold fast. If we don’t hold fast our original belief is in vain.

In the context of persecution Jesus said that it is “the one who endures to the end [who] will be saved” (Mark 13:13). To believing Jews Jesus said, “If you abide in my word, you are truly my disciples” (John 8:31). True disciples will abide.

In addition to persevering warnings, there are holiness warnings also. In passages such as Galatians 5:19–21; 1 Corinthians 6:9–10; Ephesians 5:3–5, Paul addresses the church and lays out a list of sins and promises to whom the kingdom of God is not fit for.

So herein lies the problem. How can the unwavering promises of God not be contradictory to these and the many other warning passages?

How can the unwavering promises of God not be contradictory to the many other warning passages?

To resolve this tension we can find help in the narrative of Acts 27.

The Apostle Paul is a prisoner on a ship which becomes embroiled in an epic storm. After three days we are told that all hope of salvation was abandoned. But then Paul stands up and makes a stirring speech,

“Yet now I urge you to take heart, for there will be no loss of life among you, but only of the ship. For this very night there stood before me an angel of the God to whom I belong and whom I worship, and he said, ‘Do not be afraid, Paul; you must stand before Caesar. And behold, God has granted you all those who sail with you.’ So take heart, men, for I have faith in God that it will be exactly as I have been told.”

That is the unwavering promise of God’s protection.

As the story continues some of the soldiers panic and attempt to escape from the ship and Paul gives them a warning, “Unless these men stay in the ship, you cannot be saved.”

So we have both a promise and a warning.

Now imagine Paul and the soldiers sitting safe around a fire later on the island, and they begin reflecting on what has happened. And finally one of the soldiers pipes up and says to Paul, “Paul you need to explain something to me, I don’t quite understand what happened out there—didn’t you promise that we would all be saved? But then how could you warn us that we won’t be saved unless we stay on the boat? Which one is true Paul? The promise or the warning?” To which Paul might respond, “Both. Both the promise and the warning were true. In fact they worked together. The purpose of the warning was to accomplish the promise. The warning was a means by which the promise would be fulfilled. You are alive here now aren’t you?” “Yes.” “And you heeded the warning didn’t you?” “Yes.” “And so you see the warning helped keep the promise.”

The purpose of the warning was to accomplish the promise. The warning was a means by which the promise would be fulfilled. 

God’s warnings do not contradict God’s promises. They are means by which the promise is fulfilled. God promises to keep us but He doesn’t do it in a vacuum; He uses means and one of those means are dreadful warnings not to fall away. 

In reality the warnings work on true Christians, and true Christians are kept in the faith by them. Others who are not true believers fall away and so the warnings become reality. These are not empty threats.

The great 19th century preacher Charles Spurgeon put it like this, “God preserves his children from falling away; but he keeps them by the use of means; and one of these is, the terrors of the law, showing them what would happen if they were to fall away. There is a deep precipice: what is the best way to keep any one from going down there? Why, to tell him that if he did he would inevitably be dashed to pieces... So God says, ‘My child, if you fall over this precipice you will be dashed to pieces.’ What does the child do? He says, ‘Father, keep me; hold thou me up, and I shall be safe.’”

We all need to hear the warnings. Christians need to hear in order to persevere. Unbelievers need to hear in order to come to Jesus.

Author: Sam Wright
Published: 26 Sep 2013

Latest Posts:

  • Join the Team – Community Pastor (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Generations Pastor (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Women’s Ministry Director (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Training Director (Melbourne)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – City Kids Coordinator (West)

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – City on a Hill Melbourne

    Join the Team –…

  • Join the Team – Services Director (West)

    Join the Team –…

  • Key Themes: Suffering

    Key Themes: Suffering

  • Key Themes: Poverty & Wealth

    Key Themes: Poverty…

  • Key Themes: Now & Tomorrow

    Key Themes: Now &…

  • Key Themes: Wisdom

    Key Themes: Wisdom

  • Key Themes: Faith & Works

    Key Themes: Faith…

  • Opportunity to Serve – Communications Coordinator Melbourne

    Opportunity to Serve…

  • Fasting: A Brief Introduction

    Fasting: A Brief…

  • Unlocking a New Room

    Unlocking a New Room

  • Join the Team – Many Rooms Kitchen Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • Opportunity to Serve – City Kids Team Leader

    Opportunity to Serve…

  • On Mission with Milene Tan

    On Mission with Milene…

  • On Mission with Kenneth Webb

    On Mission with Kenneth…

  • On Mission with Debbie Bognar

    On Mission with Debbie…

  • The Structure of Proverbs

    The Structure of…

  • City on a Hill Church Planting Fund

    City on a Hill Church…

  • His Story Our Story – Recap

    His Story Our Story…

  • 3 Tips for Reading Proverbs

    3 Tips for Reading…

  • Join the Team – Research Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • Why should we trust the Bible if it gets the origin of life so wrong? – Part III

    Why should we trust…

  • Why should we trust the Bible if it gets the origin of life so wrong? – Part II

    Why should we trust…

  • Why should we trust the Bible if it gets the origin of life so wrong? – Part I

    Why should we trust…

  • Tacos of Grace

    Tacos of Grace

  • City News September

    City News September

  • City News August

    City News August

  • Join the Team – Operations Director

    Join the Team –…

  • Welcome Dave Miers

    Welcome Dave Miers

  • City News July

    City News July

  • On Mission with Paul Distefano

    On Mission with Paul…

  • On Mission with Steve Murray

    On Mission with Steve…

  • On Mission with Rick Jordan

    On Mission with Rick…

  • Welcome Leighton Cantrill

    Welcome Leighton…

  • The Lost Art of Sorrow

    The Lost Art of Sorrow

  • Interview With Sam Wright, Pastor of Redemption Church

    Interview With Sam…

  • The Reality of Suffering and Evil

    The Reality of Suffering…

  • Join the Team – Accounts Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • The Attentive Life - Book Review

    The Attentive Life…

  • A Date with the King

    A Date with the King

  • Trusting the Grand Weaver

    Trusting the Grand…

  • City News February

    City News February

  • Songs of Summer II

    Songs of Summer II

  • City News January

    City News January

  • Generous – Quarterly Update

    Generous – Quarterly…

  • City News December

    City News December

  • Join the Team – Community Director

    Join the Team –…

  • Engage 2014

    Engage 2014

  • Planting with PlantED

    Planting with PlantED

  • Join the Team – Video Coordinator

    Join the Team –…

  • Introduction to Promises

    Introduction to Promises

  • Join the Team – XD-Ops

    Join the Team –…

  • City News November

    City News November

  • His Story Our Story – Photo Journal

    His Story Our Story…

  • Kirsty’s Story

    Kirsty’s Story

  • Pete’s Story

    Pete’s Story

  • Amy’s Story

    Amy’s Story

  • Surviving Same Sex Attraction as a Christian

    Surviving Same Sex…

  • Generous Campaign

    Generous Campaign

  • Why Bother With Predestination?

    Why Bother With Predestination?

  • City News October

    City News October

  • This Is (True) Greatness

    This Is (True) Greatness

  • The Call to Mission

    The Call to Mission

  • What About the Warnings?

    What About the Warnings?

  • The Peril of Porn

    The Peril of Porn

  • Dating For The Glory Of God

    Dating For The Glory…

  • City News September 2013

    City News September…

  • Adoption: The Gospel Made Visible

    Adoption: The Gospel…

  • You Knit Me Together

    You Knit Me Together

  • Working For God

    Working For God

  • Australia – The Results Are In

    Australia – The…

  • Thorn in the Flesh

    Thorn in the Flesh

  • Tough Questions

    Tough Questions

  • Good Grief

    Good Grief

  • An Honourable Office

    An Honourable Office

  • City News July 2013

    City News July 2013

  • Faith and Work

    Faith and Work

  • We Are Family

    We Are Family

  • WWJD: Responding To Begging

    WWJD: Responding…

  • Work. Rest. Play - Part II

    Work. Rest. Play…

  • City News - May

    City News - May

  • Salvation Happens To Us, Not By Us

    Salvation Happens…

  • Doves & Snakes

    Doves & Snakes

  • Planting & Pregnancy

    Planting & Pregnancy

  • Lest We Forget

    Lest We Forget

  • Introduction to 1 Peter

    Introduction to 1…

  • Easter 2013 – Photo Journal

    Easter 2013 – Photo…

  • More Than Gold

    More Than Gold

  • Join The Team – Music Director

    Join The Team –…

  • Jessica’s Story

    Jessica’s Story

  • Changes


  • Andy’s Story

    Andy’s Story

  • Work. Rest. Play - Part I

    Work. Rest. Play…

  • Join The Team – Biblical Living Pastor

    Join The Team –…

  • Eat, Drink & Be Merry Melbourne!

    Eat, Drink &…

  • City News – March

    City News – March